Chogan often comes up in conversations about direct selling of perfumes. The Italian brand offers fragrances that are said to be “inspired” by major houses, sold by independent distributors through a network marketing model. But what do those who have left the network after several months or even years of activity say?
Actual earnings of Chogan distributors: what the compensation plan doesn’t show
The promise of an additional income attracts many candidates. The official discourse highlights freedom, working from home, and commissions on sales. In practice, the majority of distributors do not exceed a small additional income.
Recommended read : Buying a kayak: what are the benefits?
Since 2023, several specialized directories in home sales classify Chogan as a “fully-fledged MLM” rather than just a VDI. This distinction matters: it means that to generate significant income, one must not only sell products but also recruit other distributors into their network.
In concrete terms, former distributors describe a gap between expected earnings and actual earnings. The time spent on prospecting, managing orders, and customer follow-up far exceeds what is presented during recruitment. As detailed in the user experience on Belle en Forme, several testimonials point to a disproportionate effort compared to the gains.
Read also : What is the ideal location for a treadmill?
Have you ever calculated an hourly rate for a direct selling activity? This is the exercise that discourages most former Chogan distributors. Once travel expenses, free samples, and prospecting time are taken into account, the financial balance often turns negative.
Chogan distributor and social selling: the silent transformation of the network
A recent phenomenon deserves attention. Distributors who remain active are transforming into micro-influencers on Instagram and Facebook. Unboxing reels, interactive stories asking for followers’ opinions, posts tailored to promote “the opportunity to join the team”: the format has changed.
This shift towards social selling blurs the line between sincere testimonials and promotional content. When a distributor posts a trendy reel to defend the brand, she speaks as a seller, not as a neutral consumer. Thus, the positive reviews visible on social media mostly come from people who have a financial interest in promoting Chogan.
Former distributors, on the other hand, tend to express themselves in private Facebook groups or on specialized forums. Their voices are less visible but often more detailed about the difficulties encountered.
What former distributors most often criticize
- Pressure to recruit: to progress in the compensation plan, selling is not enough. One must sponsor new members, which transforms personal relationships into business opportunities.
- The initial stock to advance: even though the entry ticket remains moderate, several former distributors report having accumulated unsold stock, especially after the first months of enthusiasm.
- Gradual isolation: without a structured local team, the distributor finds themselves alone facing prospecting. The support promised by the sponsor is sometimes limited to generic motivational messages.
- The difficulty in retaining customers: curious clients test one or two perfumes, then return to their purchasing habits in perfumeries or online.
Chogan inspired perfumes: the legality question always arises
A defensive argument consistently comes up among active distributors: an inspired perfume is not a counterfeit. The explanation is simple. Counterfeiting involves copying the brand, logo, bottle, and packaging to make it look like the original product. Chogan reproduces none of that.
The brand’s perfumes use olfactory compositions close to well-known fragrances, provided by specialized laboratories. This practice is legal. Trademark law protects the name, visuals, and packaging, not the olfactory formula itself.
For former distributors, however, this legal question is not the real issue. What has held them back is rather the customer’s perception. Explaining to a potential buyer that it is a perfume “inspired by” such or such a big name often raises suspicion. The educational work with the customer takes considerable time, and not all distributors have the sales skills to carry it out.
Why some distributors stay despite everything
Not all feedback is negative. Some former distributors acknowledge having appreciated the olfactory quality of the products. Others found in the activity a social framework, meetings, and a first entrepreneurial experience.
The difference between those who stay and those who leave often comes down to one factor: initial expectations. Those who saw Chogan as a primary income source quickly become disillusioned. Those who approached it as a hobby with a small financial bonus tend to have a more nuanced memory.
Chogan and the MLM model: signals to check before committing
Before joining a network like Chogan, a few concrete points can help evaluate the situation with clarity.
- Check whether the compensation is more based on product sales or on recruiting new members. A healthy MLM derives its income primarily from sales to end customers.
- Ask your sponsor for concrete figures on their own net monthly earnings, after expenses. Be wary of vague answers or screenshots of gross commissions.
- Inquire about the conditions for returning unsold stock. A commitment without the possibility of return increases financial risk.
The Chogan model is neither a scam in the legal sense nor the good deal that some promotional content suggests. Former distributors who testify describe a time-consuming activity, where earnings remain modest for the vast majority. The product may sometimes appeal, but the business model almost always disappoints those who hoped to make a living from it.